Browse Guides  internal medicine  pulmonology

Pleural effusion

Causes
Clinical features
Investigations
Therapy
Prognosis
Therapy

Malignancy

An alternative is surgical pleurodesis using thoracoscopy a ,   using talc. b d

Why?

  • Thoracoscopic talc poudrage leads to fewer recurrent effusions than bleomycin pleurodesis. a
  • There is no clear difference in mortality rates, length of stay in hospital or use of analgesia post-procedure between the two techniques.
  • Talc is the most effective sclerosant but requires thoracoscopy. b d

Malignant effusions: thoracoscopic talc poudrage prevents recurrent effusions better than bleomycin

Patient Treatment Comparison Outcome CER RRR
(95% CI)
NNT
(95% CI)
malignant pleural effusion a thoracoscopic talc poudrage bleomycin pleurodesis recurrent effusion
at 6 months
69% 81%
(27% to 95%)
2 (1 to 4)

Expiry date: July 2003
Levels of Evidence used in grading these guides

Author   CM   Ball
Reviewer   D   Geddes
CAT Writers   D   Stanley , CM   Ball