Cardiac arrest: Nimodipine may increase the chance of having neurological deficits.
|
|
|
Clinical bottom line (level 1b-)
-
Patients who had a cardiac arrest in the community and received nimodipine compared with placebo appeared at increased risk of neurological deficits at 3 and 12 months.
|
|
Roine et al:
JAMA
1993;
269:
237-242
|
Expires
October 2003
|
The study
Double-blinded ?concealed randomised
trial
with
intention-to-treat
Setting: Advanced life support unit, Helsinki
68 patients
(aged
36 to 85; mean 65,
72%
male)
who were successfully resuscitated from a VF cardiac arrest
Excluded if
- <15 years old
- basic life support not started within 10 minutes of cardiac arrest
- advanced life support not started within 20 minutes of cardiac arrest, and spontaneous circulation not restored within 30 minutes.
- unwitnessed cardiac arrests if ventricular fibrillation was not coarse (<1 millivolt)
- study treatment not given at 30 minutes after cardiac arrest
- probable extra-cardiac causes of ventricular fibrillation (eg. trauma, exsanguination, suspected intracranial haemorrhage)
- pregnancy
- previous severe brain damage
- chronic disorder causing loss of independence in activities of daily living
- response to verbal commands immediately after resuscitation
Control Group: (n = 33, 33 analysed):
Placebo
Experimental Group: (n = 35, 35 analysed):
Nimodipine-10 micrograms per kilogram body weight intravenously after restoration of spontaneous circulation, followed by infusion of 0.5 micrograms per kilogram body weight per minute for 24 hours
100% followed for
12
months
Neurological deficits
Outcome notes:
-
no neurological deficits
: at 3 months. Determined by using Wechsler adult intelligence scale, verbal intelligence quotient, performance intelligence quotient, parts of Wechsler memory scale, memory quotient-mean 100; standard deviation 15, delayed retrieval of logical stories, associative learning- mean 85; standard deviation 7, verbal skills, motivation during tests (1, normal to 5, severe disturbances), Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (0 to 60). Scores =2 standard deviations below normal population considered moderate to severe disturbances.
-
1 or 2 neurological deficits
: at 3 months
-
more than 2 neurological deficits
: at 3 months
-
no neurological deficits
: at 12 months
-
1 or 2 neurological deficits
: at 12 months
-
more than 2 neurological deficits
: at 12 months
The evidence
| Outcome |
Time to outcome |
CER | EER | RRR (95% CI) | ARR (95% CI) | NNH (95% CI) |
| no neurological deficits
|
3
months |
16 (48.5%) |
11 (31.4%) |
35.0% (-18.0% to
65.0%) |
17.1% (-6% to
40%) |
6
(NNT =
17
to infinity;
NNH = 2 to infinity)
|
| 1 or 2 neurological deficits
|
3
months |
9 (27.3%) |
14 (40.0%) |
-47.0% (-192% to
26%) |
-12.7% (-35.0% to
9.51%) |
8
(NNT =
3
to infinity;
NNH = 11 to infinity)
|
| more than 2 neurological deficits
|
3
months |
8 (24.2%) |
10 (28.6%) |
-18.0% (-162% to
47%) |
-4.33% (-25.3% to
16.6%) |
23
(NNT =
4
to infinity;
NNH = 6 to infinity)
|
| no neurological deficits
|
12
months |
15 (45.5%) |
13 (37.1%) |
-18.0% (-54% to
45%) |
-8.31% (-31.7% to
15.0%) |
12
(NNT =
7
to infinity;
NNH = 3 to infinity)
|
| 1 or 2 neurological deficits
|
12
months |
8 (24.2%) |
10 (28.6%) |
-18.0% (-162% to
47.0%) |
-4.33% (-25.3% to
16.6%) |
23
(NNT =
4
to infinity;
NNH = 6 to infinity)
|
| more than 2 neurological deficits
|
12
months |
2 (6.06%) |
6 (17.1%) |
-183% (-1204% to
39.0%) |
-11.1% (-26.0% to
3.82%) |
9
(NNT =
4
to infinity;
NNH = 26 to infinity)
|
Comments
- The trial is too small to show a clear effect with nimodipine.
Citation
-
Roine
RO,
Kajaste
S,
Kaste
M:
Neuropsychological Sequelae of Cardiac Arrest.
JAMA
1993;
269:
237-242
Contributor: Clare Wotton & Chris Ball,
October 1999
Reviewer: William Rhoton
Clinical Question.
| Patient |
cardiac arrest |
| Intervention or Exposure |
nimodipine |
| Outcome |
neurological deficit |
|
|