Myocardial infarction: tPA causes more strokes than streptokinase.
|
|
|
Clinical bottom line (level 1b)
-
Patients with acute myocardial infarction who are given tissue plasminogen activator, are more likely to have a stroke than those given streptokinase
(NNH =
258
at
unknown)
.
-
Patients who are given tissue plasminogen activator have no clear difference in haemorrhagic or ischaemic stroke, than those given streptokinase.
-
Patients given heparin had no clear difference in stroke than those not given heparin.
|
|
Maggioni et al:
New England Journal of Medicine
1992;
327 (1):
1-6
|
Expires March 2003
|
The study
?blinded ?concealed randomised
trial
with
intention-to-treat
Setting: multicentre, Italy and Belgium
20768 patients
(aged
?,
?%
male)
chest pain with ST-segment elevation of 1mm or more in any lead of the ECG, 2 mm or more in any precordial lead, or both, and admitted within six hours of symptom onset
Excluded if
- contraindication to thrombolytic or antithrombotic treatment
Control Group: (n = 10396, 10396 analysed):
streptokinase
, 1.5 million units over a period of 30 to 60 minutes
Experimental Group: (n = 10372, 10372 analysed):
tissue plasminogen activator
, 100 mg over a three hour period
10, 361 patietns were also randomised to receive subcutaneous heparin (12, 500 units twice daily), whereas 10, 407 did not.
100% followed for
?
Outcome notes:
-
stroke
: sudden focal neurologic deficit lasting >24 hours
The evidence
| Outcome |
Time to outcome |
CER | EER | RRR (95% CI) | ARR (95% CI) | NNT (95% CI) |
| stroke
|
unknown |
98 (0.94%) |
138 (1.33%) |
-41.0% (-83.0% to
-9.00%) |
-0.39% (-0.68% to
-0.10%) |
-258
(-1005 to
-148)
|
| haemorrhagic stroke
|
unknown |
30 (0.29%) |
44 (0.42%) |
-47.0% (-134% to
8.00%) |
-0.14% (-0.30% to
0.03%) |
-737
(NNT =
336
to infinity;
NNH = 3780 to infinity)
|
| ischaemic stroke
|
unknown |
46 (0.44%) |
54 (0.52%) |
-18.0% (-74.0% to
21.0%) |
-0.08% (-0.27% to
0.11%) |
-1280
(NNT =
375
to infinity;
NNH = 908 to infinity)
|
| stroke with heparin
|
unknown |
119 (1.14%) |
117 (1.13%) |
1.00% (-27.0% to
23.0%) |
0.01% (-0.27% to
0.30%) |
7029
(NNT =
365
to infinity;
NNH = 331 to infinity)
|
Citation
-
Maggioni
AP,
Franzosi
MG,
Santoro
E, et al:
The risk of stroke in patients with acute myocardial infarction after thrombolytic and antithrombotic treatment.
New England Journal of Medicine
1992;
327 (1):
1-6
Contributor: Clare Wotton,
February 2000
Reviewer:
Clinical Question.
| Patient |
myocardial infarction |
| Intervention or Exposure |
streptokinase |
| Comparison |
tissue plasminogen activator |
| Outcome |
stroke |
Control Group: (n = 10396, 10396 analysed):
streptokinase
, 1.5 million units over a period of 30 to 60 minutes
Experimental Group: (n = 10372, 10372 analysed):
tissue plasminogen activator
, 100 mg over a three hour period
10, 361 patients were also randomised to receive subcutaneous heparin (12, 500 units twice daily), whereas 10, 407 did not.
100% followed for
?weeks
Outcome notes:
-
stroke
: sudden focal neurologic deficit lasting >24 hours
The evidence
| Outcome |
Time to outcome |
CER | EER | RRR (95% CI) | ARR (95% CI) | NNT (95% CI) |
| stroke
|
unknown |
98 (0.94%) |
138 (1.33%) |
-41.0% (-83.0% to
-9.00%) |
-0.39% (-0.68% to
-0.10%) |
-258
(-1005 to
-148)
|
| haemorrhagic stroke
|
unknown |
30 (0.29%) |
44 (0.42%) |
-47.0% (-134% to
8.00%) |
-0.14% (-0.30% to
0.03%) |
-737
(NNT =
336
to infinity;
NNH = 3780 to infinity)
|
| ischaemic stroke
|
unknown |
46 (0.44%) |
54 (0.52%) |
-18.0% (-74.0% to
21.0%) |
-0.08% (-0.27% to
0.11%) |
-1280
(NNT =
375
to infinity;
NNH = 908 to infinity)
|
| stroke with heparin
|
unknown |
119 (1.14%) |
117 (1.13%) |
1.00% (-27.0% to
23.0%) |
0.01% (-0.27% to
0.30%) |
7029
(NNT =
365
to infinity;
NNH = 331 to infinity)
|
Citation
-
Maggioni
AP,
Franzosi
MG,
Santoro
E, et al:
The risk of stroke in patients with acute myocardial infarction after thrombolytic and antithrombotic treatment.
New England Journal of Medicine
1992;
327 (1):
1-6
Contributor: Clare Wotton,
February 2000
Reviewer: Chris Ball
Clinical Question.
| Patient |
myocardial infarction |
| Intervention or Exposure |
streptokinase |
| Comparison |
tissue plasminogen activator |
| Outcome |
stroke |
|
|