Myocardial infarction: streptokinase was cost effective.
|
|
|
Clinical bottom line (level 2b)
-
In elderly patients with acute myocardial infarction streptokinase treatment was cost effective.
-
Streptokinase was slightly more cost-effective in 80 year old patients than in 70 or 75 year olds.
|
|
Krumholz et al:
New England Journal of Medicine
1992;
327 (1):
7-13
|
Expires March 2003
|
The study
Cost-effectiveness analysis
Setting: general hospital, USA
Data was from patients aged 75 years or more who presented with ST-segment elevation within six hours of onset of the symptoms, suggesting myocardial infarction. Patients either received thrombolytics with streptokinase or no thrombolysis at all.
- Viewpoint: hospital
- Benefit assessment: cost per life year saved
- Resources and costs: Data from the GISSI and ISIS-2 trials were used to estimate mortality, stroke and other complications. The cost of administering streptokinase at the general hospital was $200 per patient. The costs of treatment for bleeding complications included the hospital costs for a transfusion of two units of packed red cells at the hospital and the cost of two additional days in the cardiac care unit- approximately $1, 600. On the basis of informal information from a rehabilitation hospital, the cost of caring for a patient with a severe neurological deficit was estimated to be $200, 000 per year. Average annual medical costs related to coronary heart disease after infarction were estimated at $2, 100 per year. Medical costs unrelated to coronary heart disease were considered to be $4, 400 annually. The cost of a reinfarction attributable to thrombolysis was estimated to be $10, 000. Life expectancy after MI was calculated with the use of Coronary Heart Disease Policy Model as 5.5 years for a 70 year old and 2.7 years for an 80 year old. Costs were expressed as 1990 dollars and were discounted at 5% per year.
- Sensitivity analysis: Cost of thrombolytic therapy ($100-$2, 000), cost of bleeding complication ($2, 400 to $16,00; baseline $1, 600), rate of bleeding complications (3% to 25%; baseline 0.3%), cost of care for a stroke ($300, 000 to $1, 000, 000; baseline $200, 000), overall rate of stroke (2% to 6%; baseline 1.3%), in-hospital mortality and total medical care costs were altered.
The evidence
| intervention |
cost |
| streptokinase in a 70 year old
|
$21, 600
( per year of life saved
)
|
| streptokinase in a 75 year old
|
$22, 400
( per year of life saved
)
|
| streptokinase in an 80 year old patient
|
$21, 200
( per year of life saved
)
|
Effect of sensitivity analysis: the sensitivity analyses only had an effect at the extremes.
- Cost-effectiveness of streptokinase was compared with no thrombolysis.
Comments
- The informal nature of cost, and lack of account for utility issues, makes for less reliability in this analysis.
- The clinical data is taken from two large trials. A newer analysis may use larger trials or meta-analyses of thrombolytic treatment and provide different answers.
Citation
-
Krumholz
HM,
Pasternak
RC,
Weinstein
MC, et al:
Cost effectiveness of thrombolytic therapy with streptokinase in elderly patients with suspected acute myocardial infarction.
New England Journal of Medicine
1992;
327 (1):
7-13
Contributor: Clare Wotton and Bob Phillips,
February 2000
Reviewer:
Clinical Question.
| Patient |
elderly patients with myocardial infarction |
| Intervention or Exposure |
streptokinase |
| Comparison |
no thrombolysis |
| Outcome |
cost-effectiveness |
The evidence
| intervention |
cost |
| streptokinase in a 70 year old
|
$21, 600
( per year of life saved
)
|
| streptokinase in a 75 year old
|
$22, 400
( per year of life saved
)
|
| streptokinase in an 80 year old patient
|
$21, 200
( per year of life saved
)
|
Effect of sensitivity analysis: the sensitivity analyses only had an effect at the extremes.
- Cost-effectiveness of streptokinase was compared with no thrombolysis.
Comments
- The informal nature of cost, and lack of account for utility issues, makes for less reliability in this analysis.
- The clinical data is taken from two large trials. A newer analysis may use larger trials or meta-analyses of thrombolytic treatment and provide different answers.
Citation
-
Krumholz
HM,
Pasternak
RC,
Weinstein
MC, et al:
Cost effectiveness of thrombolytic therapy with streptokinase in elderly patients with suspected acute myocardial infarction.
New England Journal of Medicine
1992;
327 (1):
7-13
Contributor: Clare Wotton and Bob Phillips,
February 2000
Reviewer:
Clinical Question.
| Patient |
elderly patients with myocardial infarction |
| Intervention or Exposure |
streptokinase |
| Comparison |
no thrombolysis |
| Outcome |
cost-effectiveness |
|
|